Can a niche go mass and stay a niche?
Hummus without tahini, Lanthimos and Östlund films without open questions. The edges a niche loses to please everyone are often why the first people loved it.
A while ago, a colleague told me that hummus is a bit overused. That it’s the default snack now, and it’s everywhere.
I didn’t really know what to say.
I’m from southern Türkiye, and both my parents come from Levantine minorities. I grew up with this food. For me, hummus is still a special thing when it’s done well. And it’s not easy to do well.
So how can the same food be boring for him and special for me?
At first I thought, maybe hummus was never that special, and I’m just attached to it.
Then I looked at what is actually on the shelves here in the Netherlands. No garlic taste, almost no lemon, barely any tahini. Half of them are “hummus with” something, and anything with chickpeas gets the name. People don’t even think tahini is a must.
So yes, hummus reached everyone. But which hummus?
It’s definitely not the original that travelled. It’s just the easygoing version.
The garlic, the lemon, the tahini, ideally a good olive oil. These are exactly the parts that ask something from you. They have strong “personalities”. People might not like them the first time. Barely use them, or even take them out, and nobody is bothered anymore.
But nobody is excited either.
If we’ve talked enough about my favorite topic, food, let’s think a bit about my second favorite topic, cinema.
There are two directors I find really interesting here: Yorgos Lanthimos and Ruben Östlund. Both started with niche films and a small audience. Dogtooth. Force Majeure.
I can talk about them for hours, but in short, what I loved about those early films is that they were open. You left the cinema and you had to think about it. What did that ending mean? What the hell was that? Nobody handed you the answer, and in fact, everyone had a different answer.
And today? Poor Things, Triangle of Sadness... Big stars, bigger budgets, and there you go. Full cinemas, followed by awards.
You could argue they’re still not classic Hollywood, and to be fair, they still look stranger than most of what’s out there. I can’t deny that.
But the films now tell you what they mean. The metaphor is pushed to you, and then explained one more time, just in case.
There’s nothing left to discuss.
So it looks like they reached everyone, and it looks like the strange look survived. But those open questions didn’t make it.
And I think that’s the “tahini”.
A niche doesn’t reach the masses. A version of it might, with the demanding part removed, under the same packaging.
From the outside it looks like the niche got big and now everybody loves it. I don’t think that’s possible without making it more generic. And then it’s not the same thing anymore.
That’s not necessarily bad. My colleague knows what hummus is. More people watch a Lanthimos film than ever. But let’s not call it the same product.
Is there an exception? I’m still thinking about it, and looking for one like crazy.
Maybe there are two ways to get big. You remove what’s demanding, and people come in fast. Or you keep it and you wait. The second one is rare, it’s slow, and you carry the risk the whole time. Like Ghibli did. Spirited Away reached a global mass audience without explaining itself.
We love sanding down the edges. Reach more people, smooth the onboarding, make it easier to like. Most of the time that’s the right call.
But sometimes those edges are the reason the first people loved it.
What is the “tahini” in your product? And are you about to take it out so more people can like it?






I really enjoyed reading this post, especially getting a peak into what you like.